Xcheque

CROSS CHECKING THE PAST, PRESENT AND FUTURE OF GLOBAL DAIRY INDUSTRY VALUE

balloon logo

XCHEQUE BLOG

  
Not an Xcheque user?  Register here
Recover your  Username  or  Password
specsNeed Specs? Try CTRL + (plus)
Blog List
Global
17 Dec 09
Dr Jon Hauser
29 Apr 10
Dr Jon Hauser
7 May 10
Dr Jon Hauser
7 May 10
Dr Jon Hauser
16 Jul 10
Dr Jon Hauser
19 Aug 10
Dr Jon Hauser
21 Aug 10
Dr Jon Hauser
24 Aug 10
Dr Jon Hauser
15 Oct 10
Dr Jon Hauser
11 Nov 10
Dr Jon Hauser
7 Jan 11
Dr Jon Hauser
7 Jan 11
Neil Lane
26 Jan 11
Neil Lane
20 Feb 11
Dr Jon Hauser
Australia
23 Nov 09
Neil Lane
23 Nov 09
Dr Jon Hauser
30 Nov 09
Dr Jon Hauser
16 Dec 09
Neil Lane
31 Dec 09
Dr Jon Hauser and Neil Lane
26 Mar 10
Dr Jon Hauser
20 May 10
Neil Lane
22 Jun 10
Dr Jon Hauser
3 Sep 10
Dr Jon Hauser
13 Sep 10
Dr Jon Hauser
15 Oct 10
Neil Lane
11 Nov 10
Neil Lane
24 Dec 10
Neil Lane
26 Jan 11
Dr Jon Hauser
20 Feb 11
Neil Lane
17 Mar 11
Dr Jon Hauser
New Zealand
21 Nov 09
Dr Jon Hauser
8 Dec 09
Dr Jon Hauser
10 Apr 10
Dr Jon Hauser
29 Apr 10
Dr Jon Hauser
25 Sep 10
Dr Jon Hauser
11 Dec 10
Dr Jon Hauser
28 Feb 11
Dr Jon Hauser
USA
19 Mar 10
Dr Jon Hauser
20 Nov 10
Dr Jon Hauser
31 Mar 11
Dr Jon Hauser
Europe
16 Apr 10
Dr Jon Hauser
22 Apr 10
Dr Jon Hauser
29 Apr 10
Dr Jon Hauser
10 Feb 11
Dr Jon Hauser

Making sense out of units of milk price

Neil Lane   Xcheque.com   18th January 2011  
Print | PDF

Wherever you go in the world we hear millk price expressed in different units or currencies ? no wonder there is so much confusion when comparing milk price within a country let alone between countries. Here is a short roundup of the pricing systems used within the major global dairy trading nations.

New Zealand - $/kg Milksolids where Milk Solids = (Fat + Crude Protein) is truly a NZ?ism,  $/kgMS while not perfect is the best method for expressing a comparative milk price because it has the least amount of error caused by different butterfat and protein %.  

Australia - Unfortunately we have the very imprecise cents/litre ingrained into our vernacular. I have to confess that I can be as guilty as the next person. In my defence however I have an unspoken standard litre in mind when I quote a cents/litre price (4.0% Butterfat and 3.2% Protein). What we should have done here in Australia is adopt $/kg Milksolids when we moved from paying purely on $/kg of butterfat to compositional milk payments in the early 1980?s. It does concern me that I?m old enough to remember when milk was paid for on a $/kg butterfat basis, and I do recall quoting milk price in this archaic denomination as recently as 5-6 years ago. One thing the influx of New Zealand dairy farmers imported with them to Australia is the term $/kgMS.  In this case however there is a subtle but not insignificant difference where in Australia Milk Solids = (Butterfat + True Protein)

USA - $ per hundred weight.  ($/cwt). Note that a US short hundred weight (100lb) shouldn?t be confused with a British Long hundred weight (112lb). $/cwt is no more a useful comparative milk price measurement than cents per litre. In each case the real price paid is a function of the milk components.

European Union ? euro/100 kg. The Europeans express their milk price in kilogram. By definition 1.0 litre of water = exactly 1.0kg (at standard temperature and pressure). However 1.0 litre of milk = 1.027-1.033kg (ie milk weighs slightly heavier than water). Therefore 1.0 kg of milk = 0.968-0.974 litres.  As with cents/litre and $/cwt, euro/100kg fails the comparison test

United Kingdom ? pence/litre. So just when you thought you?d seen every variation, the English use pence per litre. Very similar to cents/litre, $/cwt and euro/100 kg in that it there is no consideration of the protein and butterfat %.

Making neither head nor tail of international milk price units

Why $/kgMS is best but not perfect? - $/kg Milksolids is as simple as dividing the net milk income by the total Milksolids (where milk solids = kg fat + kg Protein). The error in this pricing system arises because variations in the price ratio of butterfat to protein. In most of the important western dairying regions of the world protein is valued at the farm gate somewhere between 2-3 times the value of butterfat.

Let?s consider a very simple pricing formula where we have $3.00/kg butterfat, $7.50/kg Protein and 2.5 cents/litre volumes charge therefore when the protein to fat ratio is high eg 3.6% butterfat and 3.3% protein versus 5.3% butterfat and 3.6% protein:

  $/kgMS Cents/litre Protein:Butterfat
3.6% Butterfat & 3.3% Protein $4.79 33.1 92%
5.3% Butterfat & 3.6% Protein $4.54 40.4 68%
% Difference 5.2% 22.2%  


So as you can see while there is an error in $/kgMS it is ? of what you would find with cents/litre, $/cwt, pence/litre, euro/100 kg.

Converting cents per litre to $/kgMS - When your NZ expat neighbour starts quoting their milk price in $/kgMS how do you convert cents per litre quickly into $/kgMS or vice versa. Let?s say your milk is testing somewhere around 4.0% butterfat and 3.2% protein.  In one litre of your average milk there is 40 grams of butterfat and 32 grams of protein or 72 grams of Milksolids. Therefore to produce 1 kg (1000grams of Milksolids) requires 1000/72 = 13.89 litres. That?s your number. Multiply your cents per litre price (say 30 cents/litre) by 13.89 (rounded up to 14) and waa laa $4.20 kg/MS. What you need to do in this case is learn your 14 times tables from about 20 to 45 and it will become a bit of a party trick. If you have a Jersey herd with an average of 5.0% butterfat and 3.7% protein then your conversion factor will be 1000/87=11.49. The more you do this calculation for your own average components the more you?ll soon find yourself talking with a modicum of confidence in $/kgMS ? and you?ll be all the better for it!!

I hear you say this is all well and good but what I want to do is an exact comparison. What you need to do is go to the world famous Xcheque milk price calculator. Further development and instruction is promised for this calculator so bookmark the page and keep an eye out for updates.